RECENT  POSTS:  » Read: Federal judge calls MS's marriage ban what it is: discriminatory » Yet another federal judge accurately notes crude discrimination within Arkansas' marriage ban » Prominent conservative outlet equates LGBT activists with Nazi paramilitary » New pledge: Conservative pastors choose to separate selves from civil marriage » Read: ADF creates fake 'victim' superbook; misapplies business matters to churches » P&G reaches out to pro-discrimination activist, learns it made right choice » In prep for Pope's 2015 visit, World Meeting of Families readies gay stigma, exclusion » Today in ambition: NOM cofounder vows to fight marriage equality for 100 years » Video: Mississippian who made soldier his lifestyle choice seeks freedom based on unchosen orientation » One of America's most anti-gay organizations rallies for the Duggars; because of course they would  

« Go back a post || Return to G-A-Y homepage || Haul tail to next post »

03/19/2009

Uncivil: Randy counters civil rights with 'counterfeit' claims

by Jeremy Hooper

Ya know, we just can't win with social conservatives. If our unions are recognized in civil law as marriages, then they say we are destroying all that is holy in the world. But even if we leave the word to the heteros and instead get an alternate system that shores up some of the civil benefits and protections that comes with full marriage, they still liken our relationships to cheaters, scoundrels, and thieves.

This from Randy Thomasson:

Counterfeits always harm society, whether it’s lying or cheating, or a teenager pretending he loves a girl just so she’ll give him sex, or the stealing that banks and other businesses endure, or the false documents that are commonplace in the black market.

I am greatly concerned how counterfeit marriages in California and other states will teach children that there’s nothing special about marriage and that homosexual relationships deserve the same honor as marriage, just with a different name. The opposite is true. No relationship deserves the same right or status of marriage between a man and a woman because sameness is utterly different from oneness
Marriage counterfeits in WA mimic California [Save California]

Well, we do agree with him that it's short-sighted to enact civil unions, domestic partnerships, or any alternate, less-than-equal system. But of course it's not because we see civil recognition of loving gay couples as a fraudulent Randy-thomassonelement. No, no -- the fraud we see is in the idea that gays deserve only piecemeal, separate-and-unequal arrangements rather than total marital parity. And to us, the counterfeiter label more ably applies to the Randy Thomassons of the world who spin nasty tales in order to strip gays not only of the full marriage enchilada, but any and every deserved gay rights gain.

Randy may find it appropriate to invoke swindlers, snake-oil salesmen, bank robbers, and bogus documents in order to denounce gay partner recognition. However, we see it as both offensive and politically unwise for him to do so. Offensive, obviously, because we know all too well that gay couples are simply seeking to put this tired issue behind us so that we can all move on with our lives, free to enjoy the same civil treatment as everyone else. But also politically unwise, because we think that those who use code words, false ideas about gays' need to "change," support for marriage bans, and unfair verbal attacks to wage "culture war" against the LGBT community should probably be hesitant about reminding the populace that scams and scammers still populate this world of ours.

space gay-comment gay-G-A-Y-post gay-email gay-writer-jeremy-hooper


Your thoughts

comments powered by Disqus

G-A-Y Comments Policy


 
Related Posts with Thumbnails