Illinois Family Institute's Higgins: Instead of Selma & Seneca Falls, POTUS should have linked gays to pedophilia
First there's this:
Race and sex are 100 percent heritable conditions that are in all cases immutable and have no relation to volitional acts that are legitimate objects of moral assessment.
Homosexuality, on the other hand, is not 100 percent heritable, is not in all cases immutable, and is constituted by volitional acts that are legitimate objects of moral assessment. A more sound analogy would compare homosexuality to polyamory or pedophilia (or for those who put finer distinctions on the condition currently being renamed “minor-attracted persons,” there is pedophilia, hebephilia, and ephebophilia).
Then there's this:
First, those who choose to place their same-sex attraction at the center of their identity are “treated like anyone else under the law.” They are perfectly free to participate in the sexually complementary institution of marriage. They choose not to. They are not asking to be treated equally. They are demanding to be treated specially. They want the unilateral right to jettison the central defining feature of marriage (i.e. sexual complementarity)—something, by the way, that polygamists, polyamorists, “minor-attracted persons,” and sibling-lovers are not permitted to do.
Second, does our president actually believe the idea he clunky articulated in his speech, that “surely the love we commit to one another must be equal as well”? Does he believe the love polygamists “commit” to their wives “must be equal as well”? Does he believe the love a high school teacher commits to his student “must be equal as well”? Does he believe the love five polyamorists of assorted genders “commit” to one another “must be equal” as well? Does he believe the love a brother and sister “commit” to each other “must be equal as well”?
It's always self-destructive when practitioners of the anti-equality movement link homosexuality to things like pedophilia and incest, since the nasty overreaches only help our side show how far the anti-LGBT agenda can and does go. But you know who really shouldn't do it? Someone who works for the leading policy group in a state when marriage equality is currently before the legislator.
But you just go ahead and keep on denigrating us, Laurie Higgins. We already have one person with Illinois ties helping move the polls in our direction. But if you want to help the cause too, then keep up your usual work.
comments powered by Disqus