RECENT  POSTS:  » Whether justified or Kim Davis-ed, individualistic rage rarely outplays broader truths » Kim Davis: The almost too perfect coda to the marriage discrimination fight » Anti-gay clerks are going to have to do their jobs. Because of course they are. » Jeb really wants to remind voters of his anti-'same status' plan for gay couples » Maine: NOM finally forced to hand over its tiny, out-of-state, incestuous donor roll » This delusional primary: Huckabee claims 'same-sex marriage is not the law of the land' » The 'Yeah. Duh. Of course' phase of this fight » Trailer: 'Stonewall' » And now NOM is literally pleading with its (theoretical) supporters » Add 'professional advocate for anti-gay scouting' to list of bygone career choices  

« Go back a post || Return to G-A-Y homepage || Haul tail to next post »

07/31/2014

But does the Archbishop even believe in gay?

by Jeremy Hooper

Archbishop-Nienstedt Resized 2 While allegations swirl around him, John Nienstedt, the head of the Archdiocese of St. Paul and Minneapolis who was extremely active in his state's unsuccessful fight to write discrimination into its constitution (they wrote equality into it instead), offered this statement to the Star Tribune:

“I’m not gay,” he said. “And I’m not anti-gay.” [Star Tribune]

But the thing is, if we are to judge him by his own conservative Catholic standard, there is absolutely no substance attached to this statement.

For years I've listened to every prominent conservative Catholic who fights against me, my sexual orientation, and my associated rights insist on making a distinction between my personhood and my "attractions." Conservative Catholics who fight on the anti-equality side never use the word gay. Jennifer Roback Morse, a conservative Catholic if there ever was one, "explained" it all a few years back when she said that people who share her view "don't really accept the category of gayness."

And if that's a true assessment (and it certainly comports with what I've monitored for all these years), then Ninestedt saying he isn't gay (or anti-gay) could be both true and meaningless. If following the logic, his self-assessment is kind of like him saying he's not a superhero. If he doesn't believe that people can even be gay, instead being only fallen people with "same-sex attractions," then his pontification (so to speak) around the word holds no water—holy or otherwise.

***

*Oh, but to be clear: he is very anti-gay.

space gay-comment gay-G-A-Y-post gay-email gay-writer-jeremy-hooper


Your thoughts

comments powered by Disqus

G-A-Y Comments Policy


 
Related Posts with Thumbnails